Underdog Parlays Guide 2026: Multi-Pick Strategy, Payouts & Winning Tips

_{This page contains references to products from one of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. For an explanation of our Affiliate Policy, visit this page.}

The platform allows users to combine 2-5 player propositions (commonly called Pick’ems) into a single entry, with payout multipliers that increase based on the number of selections you include. This structure rewards strategic thinking and confident predictions while maintaining the skill-based player evaluation that defines quality daily fantasy sports.

Understanding Underdog’s payout structure is essential before building your entries. A 2-pick combination pays 3x your stake, 3-pick entries pay 6x, 4-pick entries deliver 10x, and maximum 5-pick entries offer an impressive 20x multiplier. These fixed multipliers eliminate complicated odds calculations and make potential returns immediately clear.

Since Underdog operates differently from traditional sportsbooks, with exclusive focus on player performance rather than game outcomes, this comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to know. You’ll learn how to construct winning multi-pick entries, understand the strategic differences from traditional parlays, calculate your payouts, and implement proven strategies that maximize your edge.

How To Place A Pick’em Entry on Underdog

Building and submitting a multi-pick entry on Underdog is remarkably straightforward. The platform’s intuitive interface guides you through the selection process, and the entire entry creation takes less than two minutes once you’re familiar with the system.

Step-by-Step Entry Process:

1. Launch the Underdog app on your mobile device or access the website via desktop browser
2. Navigate to the Pick’em section from the main menu
3. Select the “Higher/Lower” tab to view available player propositions
4. Choose your preferred sport from the available options (NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, etc.)
5. Browse player propositions and add your selections to your entry slip (minimum 2 picks, maximum 5 picks)
6. Review your entry slip, which displays all selected props and the automatic payout multiplier
7. Enter the amount you want to risk in the stake field
8. Verify your total potential payout (displayed clearly before submission)
9. Click “Submit” to finalize and enter your player proposition multi-pick entry

One key advantage of Underdog’s system is transparency. The platform shows your exact payout before you confirm the entry—no complex odds calculations or confusion about potential returns. If you select three player props and risk $20, you immediately see your potential $120 payout (6x multiplier) displayed on the entry slip.

The interface also allows you to easily modify your entry before submission. Remove picks that no longer feel confident, add additional players as you identify value, or adjust your stake amount based on your conviction level. Once you click submit, however, the entry is locked and cannot be edited or cancelled.

Understanding Multi-Pick Entries: The Parlay Concept

Multi-pick entries (commonly called parlays in traditional sports betting) contain multiple selections—two or more—combined into a single ticket. This format differs fundamentally from placing individual, standalone entries on each selection.

The defining characteristic of multi-pick entries is that the payouts multiply rather than add. This creates significantly larger potential returns compared to separate single entries, but comes with increased risk since all selections must be correct for the entry to win.

Traditional Parlay Example (For Context)

To understand the value proposition, consider a traditional sportsbook example:

Imagine you want to back two point spread selections, each priced at standard -110 odds. If you combine both picks in a 2-team parlay, the combined odds would be approximately +264. Risking $100 on this parlay would generate $264 profit if both teams cover the spread.

Compare this to placing both selections as individual entries: Risking $100 on each selection means $200 total staked. If both win, you’d profit approximately $90.91 per win, totaling $181.82 profit. The parlay approach generates $264 profit with only $100 risked, while separate entries produce $181.82 profit but require $200 investment.

The parlay provides both better profit potential and better risk efficiency, which explains why multi-pick formats are so popular among sports gaming enthusiasts.

The All-or-Nothing Nature

However, multi-pick entries are high-risk, high-reward ventures. For your entry to win, all selections must be correct. A single incorrect prediction causes the entire entry to lose, regardless of how many other selections hit.

This all-or-nothing structure means that an 8-pick entry can fail because of one careless selection, even if the other seven predictions were perfect. This reality makes selection quality and pick count optimization critical strategic considerations.

Same-Game Multi-Pick Entries on Underdog

Same-game parlays (SGPs) have become incredibly popular at traditional sportsbooks because they allow you to combine multiple selections from a single game into one entry. This creates unique correlation opportunities—for instance, if you expect a high-scoring game, you might combine the over on total points with multiple player scoring props.

At traditional sportsbooks, same-game parlays might combine moneyline selections, game totals, and various prop bets all from one matchup. However, since Underdog operates as a fantasy sports platform rather than a sportsbook, your same-game options differ from traditional SGP offerings.

On Underdog, you can’t combine traditional betting markets like moneylines, spreads, and totals because these markets don’t exist on the platform. Instead, you create same-game multi-picks by selecting multiple player props from the same contest.

Same-Game Player Prop Example:

Suppose the Kansas City Chiefs are playing the Cleveland Browns. You could build a same-game multi-pick entry featuring players from one or both teams:

• Travis Kelce – Higher 89.5 Receiving Yards
• Patrick Mahomes – Higher 290.5 Passing Yards
• Baker Mayfield – Higher 266.5 Passing Yards

This 3-pick entry pays 6x your stake if all three quarterbacks and tight end exceed their projected stat lines. The correlation strategy here anticipates a high-volume passing game where both teams throw frequently, which would boost passing and receiving statistics for featured players.

Same-game multi-picks on Underdog offer strategic advantages when you’ve identified game environments likely to produce specific outcomes. Weather conditions, pace of play, offensive scheme matchups, and injury situations all create opportunities where multiple player props from one game might correlate positively.

Player Multi-Pick Entries: Underdog’s Specialty

Player multi-pick entries represent Underdog’s core offering. These entries exclusively combine player propositions, focusing on individual statistical achievements rather than team or game outcomes.

While you can’t place traditional betting markets on Underdog, the platform’s extensive player prop selection rivals and often exceeds what traditional sportsbooks offer. Players who enjoy proposition-based contests find Underdog’s player-focused approach refreshing and strategically engaging.

Most individual selections within player multi-picks deal with common statistical categories:

• Passing yards, passing touchdowns, completions
• Receiving yards, receptions, receiving touchdowns
• Rushing yards, rushing attempts, rushing touchdowns
• Points, rebounds, assists (basketball)
• Hits, runs, RBIs, strikeouts (baseball)
• Goals, assists, shots on goal (hockey/soccer)

When creating player multi-picks on Underdog, you must select a minimum of 2 player propositions, and your entry is capped at 5 total picks. This range balances accessibility (2-picks are achievable even for casual players) with upside potential (5-picks offer 20x multipliers for confident lineups).

Cross-Sport Multi-Pick Example

One unique advantage of Underdog’s format is the ability to combine player props across different sports in a single entry. Here’s a maximum 5-pick example spanning multiple leagues:

• Tom Brady (NFL) – Higher 266.5 Passing Yards
• Karim Benzema (Soccer) – Higher 2.5 Shots
• Cooper Kupp (NFL) – Lower 7.5 Receptions
• Luka Dončić (NBA) – Higher 31.5 Points
• Travis Kelce (NFL) – Higher 89.5 Receiving Yards

Since this is a 5-pick entry, hitting all five predictions correctly triggers the 20x payout multiplier. A $50 stake would return $1,000 total ($950 profit + $50 stake) if all selections prove accurate.

The ability to mix sports offers strategic flexibility. If you have strong convictions about specific players across different leagues, you can combine them into a single high-value entry rather than scattering your bankroll across multiple separate contests.

Traditional Parlay Types Not Available on Underdog

To fully understand Underdog’s offering, it’s helpful to know what traditional parlay types the platform doesn’t support. This clarity prevents confusion and helps set appropriate expectations for new users.

Moneyline Parlays (Not Available)

Moneyline parlays are staples at traditional sportsbooks, where bettors combine multiple teams to win their games outright. These are particularly popular for pooling together several low-priced favorites into a single entry that offers better payout than individual moneyline bets.

For example, you might combine three -200 favorites into a parlay that pays positive odds. However, since Underdog doesn’t offer moneyline betting (focusing instead on player performance), you cannot build moneyline parlays on the platform.

Point Spread Parlays (Not Available)

Point spread parlays combine multiple spread selections, where each team must cover their assigned handicap for the parlay to win. Favorites need to win by more than the spread, while underdogs can lose by less than the spread and still cover.

Spread parlays are among the most common multi-pick formats at sportsbooks, but they’re unavailable on Underdog Fantasy. The platform’s DFS framework doesn’t include point spreads or handicapping, maintaining exclusive focus on player statistics.

Totals (Over/Under) Parlays (Not Available)

Totals parlays involve multiple over/under selections on combined team scores. You might bet the over in a high-scoring matchup and the under in a defensive struggle, combining both into a single parlay for enhanced odds.

While Underdog does offer “higher/lower” mechanics, these apply exclusively to player stats rather than game totals. You can’t bet on whether the combined score of two teams exceeds or falls short of a number—only whether individual players exceed or fall short of their projected statistics.

If you’re specifically interested in traditional moneyline, spread, or totals parlays, you’ll need to explore licensed sportsbooks rather than daily fantasy sports platforms like Underdog.

Winning Multi-Pick Entry Strategies for Underdog

Success with multi-pick entries requires disciplined strategy and careful selection optimization. The high-risk, high-reward nature of parlay-style formats means that poor selection processes or reckless pick accumulation can devastate your bankroll quickly.

The following strategies, when implemented consistently, significantly improve your long-term profitability in multi-pick contests:

Optimize Pick Count: Fewer Is Often Better

The biggest mistake casual players make is stuffing their multi-pick entries with too many selections. While adding picks increases your potential multiplier, it dramatically reduces your hit probability.

Consider the mathematics: If each individual pick has a 60% success rate (which is strong in prop betting), a 2-pick entry has a 36% chance of hitting (0.60 × 0.60 = 0.36). A 5-pick entry at the same 60% individual rate drops to just 7.8% hit probability (0.60^5 = 0.078).

This means you need to win significantly more per 5-pick hit to justify the dramatically lower hit rate. While the 20x multiplier seems attractive, you’ll hit 5-pick entries far less frequently than 2-3 pick entries.

Strategic Recommendation: Focus primarily on 2-4 pick entries. These offer respectable multipliers (3x to 10x) while maintaining achievable hit rates. Reserve 5-pick entries for special situations where you’ve identified multiple exceptional value opportunities in the same slate.

Remember: one unnecessary selection can cause your entire entry to fail. Every additional pick should provide genuine value and conviction, not just inflate your payout multiplier.

Build Correlated Entries

Correlated entries are multi-picks where the success of one selection increases the probability that other selections also succeed. This correlation reduces effective risk while maintaining the same payout multiplier.

Game Environment Correlation: If you expect a fast-paced, high-scoring game between two offenses, multiple passing and receiving props from both teams become positively correlated. The game environment that helps one quarterback exceed projections likely helps the opposing quarterback as well.

Example Correlated Entry:

• QB A passing yards – Higher
• QB B passing yards – Higher
• Top WR from Team A receiving yards – Higher

If the game script unfolds as a shootout with both teams passing extensively, all three props benefit from the same game environment. This correlation improves your effective hit rate compared to three completely independent selections.

Negative Correlation Example:

Conversely, you can use negative correlation strategically. If you expect a defensive struggle with limited possessions:

• Total points – Lower (if this market existed)
• RB rushing attempts – Higher (ground-heavy game script)
• WR receptions – Lower (limited passing volume)

Building around correlations boosts your payout possibility without sacrificing as much win probability as adding random, uncorrelated selections would.

Identify Your Highest-Conviction Plays

Not all player props offer equal value or confidence. Before building any multi-pick entry, rank your available selections by conviction level based on research, matchup analysis, and projected value.

Tier 1 (Highest Conviction): Props where you have strong statistical support, favorable matchups, and clear edge over the projection. Build your core entries around these.

Tier 2 (Moderate Conviction): Props that seem reasonable but lack overwhelming evidence. These can supplement Tier 1 plays in larger entries but shouldn’t dominate your picks.

Tier 3 (Low Conviction): Speculative picks or long-shot values. Avoid including these in multi-picks—they’re the selections that cause otherwise good entries to fail.

Construct your multi-picks exclusively from Tier 1 and select Tier 2 plays. Discipline in selection quality separates profitable players from those who chase big multipliers with low-probability combinations.

Consider Hedging and Cash-Out Options

When your multi-pick entry is down to the final selection and the first picks have already hit, you face a critical decision: let it ride or protect your profit.

Hedging Strategy: You can hedge by placing a contrary selection on your final pick. For example, if your final pick is “Player X Higher 25.5 points,” you could place a single entry on “Player X Lower 25.5 points” at another platform or in a separate Underdog entry.

This guarantees profit regardless of the final outcome, though it reduces your maximum upside. Calculate whether the guaranteed profit from hedging exceeds the expected value of letting the original entry ride.

Cash-Out Feature: Some DFS platforms now offer cash-out functionality where you can settle your entry early for a guaranteed amount. If Underdog offers this feature and quotes you a substantial cash-out value with picks remaining, seriously consider taking it rather than risking everything on the final selections.

Most professional players lean toward securing profit when offered favorable hedges or cash-outs, particularly on larger stakes. Guaranteed returns beat hoping for perfect outcomes, especially given the variance in player prop performance.

Diversify Entry Sizes and Structures

Don’t commit your entire slate to one multi-pick structure. Instead, diversify across different entry sizes and compositions:

• Build multiple 2-3 pick entries featuring your highest-conviction plays
• Create one or two 4-5 pick entries when you’ve identified multiple quality opportunities
• Experiment with different player combinations rather than forcing all picks into one mega-entry
• Vary your stake sizes based on conviction—larger stakes on high-confidence small entries, smaller stakes on speculative large entries

This diversification approach smooths variance, increases your chances of hitting at least one entry, and prevents you from having all your eggs in one basket.

Maximizing Your Underdog Multi-Pick Success

Becoming consistently profitable with multi-pick entries requires more than just understanding the mechanics. You need to leverage all available resources, optimize your bankroll management, and stay informed about the broader Underdog ecosystem.

For players new to the platform, taking advantage of introductory promotions provides crucial starting capital. This bonus bankroll allows you to test different multi-pick strategies without immediately risking your deposited funds, accelerating your learning curve.

Understanding where Underdog operates ensures you’re eligible for all contest types in your jurisdiction. Some states have restrictions on specific formats, so familiarizing yourself with local regulations prevents issues when attempting to enter multi-pick contests.

Financial management significantly impacts your multi-pick sustainability. Learning about deposit methods, withdrawal options, and processing times helps you efficiently move money when you want to capitalize on favorable slates or cash out after profitable sessions.

During the NFL season, the platform offers exceptional value with extensive player proposition coverage. Many successful multi-pick players concentrate their activity during football months when the volume of available props and research materials peaks.

For those specifically interested in individual player performance prediction rather than multi-pick combinations, understanding the nuances of single-entry Underdog props provides foundational knowledge that improves your multi-pick selection quality.

Bankroll sustainability depends heavily on efficient deposit and withdrawal practices. Familiarizing yourself with Underdog banking methods ensures smooth transactions and helps you understand which payment options offer the fastest processing when you need funds quickly.

New users should investigate current Underdog promotional offers that provide bonus funds specifically usable in Pick’em contests. Starting with house money reduces risk while you refine your multi-pick strategy and develop your player evaluation skills.

Existing players can supplement their contest bankroll through the referral program. Sharing your Underdog experience with friends who enjoy player props creates ongoing earning opportunities beyond contest winnings themselves.

Beyond traditional multi-pick entries, the platform continues expanding its product offerings. Alternative approaches to sports engagement provide additional ways to apply your knowledge and diversify your strategy, though these features operate separately from standard Pick’em contests.

For football enthusiasts specifically, deep-diving into Underdog NFL strategies can significantly improve your multi-pick success during the most popular DFS season. The concentration of research materials, statistical resources, and sharp analysis during football months creates edges unavailable in other sports.

Frequently Asked Questions About Underdog Multi-Picks

What’s the minimum number of picks required?

The minimum number of picks for a multi-pick entry on Underdog is 2 selections. You can combine 2-5 player propositions in a single entry, with payout multipliers of 3x, 6x, 10x, and 20x respectively.

Do all my picks need to hit to win?

Yes, multi-pick entries on Underdog follow all-or-nothing rules. Every single selection in your entry must be correct for the entry to win. If even one pick misses, the entire entry loses regardless of how many other selections hit correctly.

Can I combine picks from different sports?

Yes, Underdog allows you to combine player props from different sports in a single multi-pick entry. You could include NFL players, NBA players, and MLB players all in the same entry if games from those sports are running simultaneously.

What happens if one of my players doesn’t play?

If a player in your multi-pick entry doesn’t participate in their game (late scratch, injury, etc.), that selection is typically voided and your entry is graded based on the remaining picks. For example, a 4-pick entry with one voided player becomes a 3-pick entry with 6x payout instead of 10x. Always check Underdog’s current voiding policies for specific situations.

Can I edit my entry after submission?

No, once you submit a multi-pick entry, it cannot be edited or cancelled. This is standard across DFS platforms to prevent exploitation of injury news, line movement, or other information advantages that emerge after submission.

Should I always go for 5-pick entries for maximum payout?

No. While 5-pick entries offer the highest multiplier (20x), they also have significantly lower hit probability. Most successful players focus on 2-4 pick entries that balance respectable payouts with achievable hit rates. Reserve 5-pick entries for special situations where you’ve identified multiple exceptional value opportunities.

How do payouts compare to traditional sportsbook parlays?

Underdog’s fixed multipliers (3x, 6x, 10x, 20x) are generally competitive with or slightly better than equivalent parlays at traditional sportsbooks. The advantage is transparency—you always know your exact payout before submitting, with no complex odds calculations required.

Important Terms and Disclaimers

Must be 18+ (19+ in AL, NE; 19+ in CO for certain games; 21+ in AZ, MA, VA) and physically present in a state where Underdog operates. Terms apply.

Multi-pick entries are high-risk. All selections must be correct for entry to win. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Play responsibly within your means.

Gambling Problem? Get Help:

• Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit www.ncpgambling.org
• Arizona: Call 1-800-NEXT-STEP or text NEXT-STEP to 53342
• New York: Call 1-877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369)

Payout structures, maximum picks, and contest formats are subject to change. Always verify current information on the official Underdog website.